Trout Mask Replica
Captain Beefheart’s Trout Mask Replica is a terrible album, listened to, by me, in its entirety, and not abandoned after the first track, only because of the near-universal critical acclaim afforded it. In this respect, it was the most excruciating act of media consumption I have engaged in since reading Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged.
This is the apotheosis of hippie music. Not because of its sound—Trout Mask Replica has nothing in common with the psychedelic records we associate with the late 60′s. No, Captain Beefheart has managed, here, in 1969, with guitars, vocals, drums, and the occasional horn to perfectly encapsulate the worst of an already inane and self-absorbed subculture’s precipitous decline over the next 30 years.
Trout Mask Replica goes beyond being an album; it is an old, dirty, hippie, with its drug damage, bad wardrobe, false erudition, self-serious “irreverence,” cringe-inducing manner of speaking, slight greasiness, and most damningly of all, complete and utter regard for its own supposed genius. After 78 minutes of playtime, I think I can smell the thing, if that’s possible, and it’s making me nauseous. I wouldn’t want to leave this record alone in my house, lest I come home from work and find it walking around in its unwashed purple tye-die tshirt, rifling through my fridge and hitting on my sister.
I don’t mind atonality, experimentation, artifice, obfuscation, and jagged rhythms; these can all be effective artistic tools. Captain Beefheart has here employed them in a musical document so atrocious that it serves not only as an incrimination of their band, but of a subculture—and, very possibly, of an entire generation.











